When it comes to pizza, the possibilities are endless. At Odd Moe’s, we’ve seen some toppings rise above the rest as perennial favorites. Whether you’re a purist or an adventurer, we have something for everyone to enjoy. So grab a slice, sit back, and enjoy our countdown of the top ten most loved pizza toppings!

1. Pepperoni: The Timeless Classic

No list of pizza toppings would be complete without pepperoni. This spicy, slightly tangy cured meat has been a staple of American pizza for decades. Its crispy edges and savory flavor make it the perfect complement to our signature pizza crust and rich tomato sauce. At Odd Moe’s, our pepperoni is a crowd-pleaser, often the first choice for both first-time visitors and seasoned regulars.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Pepperoni:

• Lineman
• Jimmy the Greek
• Power Forward
• Grand Salami

2. Mozzarella Cheese: The Gooey Essential

While it might seem like a given, mozzarella cheese deserves a spot on this list all on its own. This cheese is the cornerstone of any great pizza, known for its perfect melt and delightful stretch. At Odd Moe’s, we take pride in using only the finest, freshest mozzarella to ensure that every bite is a delightful, cheesy experience.

3. Italian Sausage: The Flavor Powerhouse

Italian sausage brings a robust and flavorful punch to any pizza. With its blend of herbs and spices, this topping pairs perfectly with our hearty red sauce and gooey cheese. It’s no wonder our customers at Odd Moe’s love it with its savory, satisfying taste that adds a bit of extra heft to any slice.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Italian Sausage:

• Lineman
• Power Forward
• Grand Salami

4. Mushrooms: The Earthy Delight

Mushrooms might be a divisive topping for some, but they’re a beloved favorite for many at Odd Moe’s. Their earthy flavor and tender texture make them a perfect partner for a variety of other toppings. Whether you prefer them on a classic combo or a veggie delight, mushrooms bring a subtle umami richness that enhances every bite. Our mushrooms are sourced fresh and sliced to perfection, adding a layer of depth and sophistication to our pizzas. Mushrooms are sure to elevate your pizza experience.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Mushrooms:

• Lineman
• Reggie
• Jimmy the Greek
• Power Forward
• The Borg

5. Pineapple: The Tropical Twist

Ah, the great pineapple debate. Love it or hate it, pineapple has secured its spot as one of the top pizza toppings at Odd Moe’s. Its sweet and tangy flavor provides a delightful contrast to the savory elements of pizza, particularly when paired with ham in the classic Hawaiian style. Pineapple is a must-have for those craving a perfect blend of sweet and savory.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Pineapple:

• The Sweet Spot
• The Bull Rider

6. Black Olives: The Salty Bite

Black olives are another divisive topping, but even if you don’t like them, they still get a spot on this list as a common favorite. Black olives add a distinct, slightly briny flavor to our pizzas that many pizza lovers just can’t get enough of. Their unique taste and firm texture make them a fantastic addition, especially when combined with other meats or vegetables. They are a common staple of our combination and veggie pizzas.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Black Olives:

• Lineman
• Reggie
• Jimmy the Greek
• The Borg
• The Big Juan

7. Green Peppers: The Crisp and Fresh

Green peppers add a refreshing crunch and a mild, sweet flavor to any pizza. At Odd Moe’s, we love using green peppers to add a bit of color and a lot of flavor to our pies. They’re particularly popular on veggie pizzas, but they also hold their own alongside more robust toppings like sausage and pepperoni.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Green Peppers:

• Lineman
• Jimmy the Greek
• The Borg

8. Onions: The Flavor Enhancer

Onions of all kinds, whether red, white, yellow, are a fantastic way to add a burst of flavor to your pizza. They caramelize beautifully in the oven, adding a sweet and savory element that enhances the overall taste of the pie. At Odd Moe’s, onions are a staple topping that pairs well with virtually everything else on the menu, and they are a classic favorite. The same goes for green onion, which we top many of our pies with.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Onions:

• Lineman – Red Onion
• Reggie – Red and Green
• Jimmy the Greek – Red Onion
• Power Forward – Green Onion
• The Borg – Red Onion
• The Big Juan – Green Onion
• The Mascot – Red and Green
• The Natural (Vegan!) – Red Onion

9. Bacon: The Crispy Indulgence

Bacon on pizza? Absolutely. This salty, crispy, and smoky topping is a fan favorite here at Odd Moe’s and around the world. It’s perfect for those who want to indulge in a little extra decadence. Whether sprinkled across the top of a meat lover’s pizza or added to a more adventurous creation, bacon brings a level of richness that’s hard to resist.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Bacon:

• The Sweet Spot – Canadian and Breakfast Bacon
• The Bull Rider – Breakfast Bacon
• Grand Salami – Canadian Bacon
• The Mascot – Breakfast Bacon

10. Spinach: The Healthy Green

Spinach is a fantastic pizza topping that is coming out on top as a favorite. It adds a touch of freshness and a vibrant green color to any pie, but is most common on ones with garlic, or veggie pizzas. At Odd Moe’s, we love incorporating spinach into our gourmet All Star pizzas, where it pairs beautifully with ingredients like garlic, feta cheese, and sun-dried tomatoes.

Odd Moe’s Pizza Featuring Bacon:

• The Green Monster
• The Natural (Vegan!)

Honorable Mentions: The Wild Cards

The Classic Cheese Pizza: Simple Yet Satisfying

There are also many people who prefer just a plain pizza with cheese and no other toppings. While we’re a big fan of toppings here at Odd Moe’s, we understand that sometimes you just can’t beat the classics. And who’s to say a plain cheese pizza isn’t still delicious all on its own with golden, bubbly mozzarella and perfectly baked crust? It’s a timeless favorite. For those who appreciate simplicity and tradition, our classic cheese pizza is a satisfying choice that never disappoints.

Other Honorable Mentions:

While these ten toppings are the stars of the show, Odd Moe’s also offers a range of other fantastic ingredients that are worth mentioning. Jalapeños bring the heat for spice lovers, anchovies add a unique umami kick, and artichoke hearts offer a tender, slightly tangy addition. And let’s not forget the various cheeses—cheddar, feta, and Parmesan—that can elevate your pizza to new heights.

Creating Your Perfect Pizza at Odd Moe’s

One of the best things about pizza is that it’s very versatile. Whether you’re a meat lover, a veggie enthusiast, or somewhere in between, you can customize your Odd Moe’s pizza to fit your exact tastes by building your own pizza. Our menu offers a variety of specialty pizzas (All Stars) that highlight these beloved toppings, but you can always create your own masterpiece from scratch.

The Odd Moe’s Experience

What sets Odd Moe’s apart is our commitment to quality and flavor. Each of our eight locations in Oregon is dedicated to providing a top-notch pizza experience. From our fresh, hand-tossed dough to our premium toppings, every pizza we make is crafted with care and attention to detail. Our friendly staff ensure that your order is prepared just the way you like it, so you can enjoy the perfect pizza experience.

Join the Conversation

We love hearing from our customers! What’s your favorite pizza topping? Do you have a go-to combination that you can’t live without? Share your thoughts with us on social media or leave a comment the next time you visit Odd Moe’s. We’re always looking for new ways to delight our pizza-loving community.

Conclusion:

There you have it—the top ten most loved pizza toppings at Odd Moe’s Pizza. We offer something for everyone on our menu, from traditional classics like cheese and pepperoni, to unique combinations. When you’re in the mood for great pizza, order from Odd Moe’s, and experience the best of Northwest-style pizza for yourself. 

Visit Us Today

With eight convenient locations to serve you in Salem, Keizer, Newberg, McMinnville, Canby, and Tanasbourne, there’s an Odd Moe’s Pizza near you. Come visit us and discover why our pizza is the talk of the town. See you soon, pizza lovers!